An Ordinary Intersection
Image via Unsplash.
Curbed's Patrick Sisson has an excellent piece on Orlando, the almost undisputed capital of pedestrian carnage in the U.S., and just how its roads got so deadly.
It's a great examination of the multifaceted nature of the problem, which isn’t just about road design but about the design of suburbia as a place on a really fundamental level. We’ve built places so spread-out and disconnected that they don’t function unless you can drive 40 or 50 miles per hour. Metropolitan Orlando is almost entirely comprised of such places. Which means that improving safety isn’t merely a street engineering challenge, or an issue of coming up with the necessary funding. It’s a deep challenge to a whole ingrained, institutionalized way of building places, and Orlando’s transportation director, Billy Hattaway (a veteran of the Florida DOT who deserves a ton of credit for pushing it to improve its bicycle and pedestrian policies) seems to understand the fight that’s required:
Next year, Hattaway will start an even bigger process with potential for greater impact, rewriting development guidelines for the city. Hattaway showed me an infamous photo of a series of homes on cul-de-sacs designed for cars and not walkability, resulting in two adjacent homes requiring seven miles of roads to get from one to the other.
“All the activists and politicians have blamed transportation as being a source of the problem,” says Hattaway. “This is equally a land development problem. It’ll actually save us money, but it requires political will to stand up to the development community.”
One later section of Sisson’s piece describes a particularly awful intersection in Pine Hills, an area I was mildly acquainted with. This made me curious, so I started poking around on Google Street View. You know, as one does.
It turns out the Google Street View car was there one day last May, right after the local high school (Maynard Evans) let out. Google has unwittingly created a photo essay of the conditions that teenagers leaving school onto Silver Star Road are expected to put up with. I present it to you here in slideshow form:
The Curbed piece quotes local bike/walk advocate Amanda Day explaining why people jaywalk here, and her explanation checks out with the Google photos:
Within an hour, we’d seen a man with a cane nearly get hit while shuffling across the road. Then Day herself, crossing with the signal, was almost struck by a car taking a right on red.
“This is why people don’t even cross at the main crosswalk,” she told me after recovering from the shock. “People simply gun it when they drive here. It’s safer to wait and cross in the middle of the block—at least they can see when cars are coming.”
If you think those pictures look like a tragedy waiting to happen, you're right. Google "pedestrian killed pine hills" and just scroll through the results page. It's numbing.
I also tried Googling "evans high school student hit by car." There too, I didn’t have to go further than the first page of search results. A senior at this school was killed in 2011—not in front of the school but on Vineland Road, a major Orlando stroad a few miles away. He was walking on the shoulder because there was no sidewalk. Jean Cherilus was an entrepreneur who sold sub sandwiches with "his mother's special sauce" to kids at school at lunch time. He was 17.
I knew before Googling I'd find a story like Jean's in no time. I just didn't know the particulars. You knew it too.
Car crashes are understood by most Americans as unavoidable tragedies. They are “just the way things are.” They’re the cost of modern living. Hopefully the photos from Street View illustrate that on Orlando's stroads (or feel free to substitute your city’s name) they're actually avoidable in a hundred different ways.
It’s clear that Hattaway and others are trying. Yet here’s another thing I knew I'd find before I found it: a history of utterly pathetic, inadequate responses to the area's safety crisis. Exhibit A: ticketing kids for jaywalking (2012). Exhibit B: recommending a phased release of students from school (this 2017 report). This is the culture Orlando’s street-safety reformers, inside and outside government, are fighting against: one in which anything other than actually slowing down traffic is what’s typically on the table.
Pine Hills is a low-income area home to Orlando's biggest Haitian population. Evans High School is 86% black, 10% white, and 11% Hispanic of any race. Low-income communities and people of color are disproportionately represented in fatal crashes involving people walking—in part because they disproportionately live in places where the infrastructure looks like those photos above.
Something else I knew I'd find about Pine Hills—in broad strokes, not particulars—is this description of its history from Wikipedia:
The area that would become Pine Hills began in 1953 … It was one of the first suburbs of Orlando and grew as a bedroom community for the workers of Martin Marietta (now Lockheed Martin). At the time, it was an upper-middle class suburb with a country club named "Silver Pines". … Eventually, as Orlando's growth surrounded Pine Hills, many of the original families moved into newer neighborhoods in nearby Ocoee, Winter Garden and MetroWest.
Into the late 1980s and during the 1990s, Pine Hills fell into a state of decline. Silver Pines Country Club was closed, and apartment complexes were built on the property in the mid 1990s. The "Pine Hills Shopping Center" lost its long-time tenants and was eventually converted in the late 1990s into "Pine Hills Marketplace", a strip mall with discount stores. As newer neighborhoods developed offering more housing options, rental rates dropped and housing became more affordable for residents. Neglect from Orange County government and little representation from Orange County Commissioners resulted in higher crime.
In other words, Pine Hills is an utterly typical fading inner-ring suburb of a type found all over the U.S. According to Wikipedia, the "primary industry in Pine Hills is retail." When it was built, it had one and exactly one selling point: affordable new houses. Now they're not new anymore.
The built environment here has clearly been a crucial factor in accelerating Pine Hills' decline. Drivers speed through a place like this on their way to elsewhere. Local businesses struggle to thrive on a road that functions like a drag strip. This is the stroad nation we’ve built: places where the roads themselves are undermining all efforts to build community, and to build wealth, on the land adjoining them.
This place is utterly normal. There are a thousand suburbs like it in America, and twenty-thousand stroads like Silver Star Road. There are tens of thousands of schools on unsafe walking routes, and hundreds of thousands of intersections like this one.
The things that ought to be horrifying about this place are utterly normal. We just don't see them most of the time, least of all when we're the ones behind the windshield. But thankfully, Google happened to drive by Evans High School 10 minutes after school let out.
This is ordinary. This is the low bar we've set for what millions of Americans who don't drive get to deal with every day. We should all be angry and ashamed.
FREE EBOOK
Build Prosperity in Your Town, One Block at a Time
Walkable, people-oriented streets are the most economically productive form of development. Here’s how to create more prosperous and safe communities for everyone.
North America's built environment makes it too dangerous for most children to walk to school. Edward Erfurt, Strong Towns' director of community action, knows that from experience. Here's how he's planning to make the street outside his son's school safer.